Airy Coconut Grove dining room with an oak table, woven chairs and a large window overlooking a lush private garden beneath a mature tree.

How to Read Coconut Grove House Prices This Fall

At the corner of Trapp Avenue and Lucaya Street in the North Grove, a 1925 cottage of 825 square feet is now joined to a 7,000-square-foot addition built in the same style. The Coconut Grove Spotlight reported on November 9 that the project was a few months from completion. It was the first restoration by TROPICA, a Grove architecture and landscape firm. In the same article, a Center Grove couple on Gifford Lane said they gave up their plan to demolish after seeing it.

That one corner says a lot about the Grove's single-family market. In 2026, finished houses in Coconut Grove are setting records. Building a new house on an inland lot now draws more neighbor involvement. Miami residents have filed at least 22 tree-removal appeals so far this year, compared with one in all of 2025. A buyer comparing the Grove with Coral Gables or Pinecrest is choosing from three kinds of property: a house that is already built, a lot that still has to be built on, and an older cottage that can be restored. Each one has to be priced differently.

What the third quarter actually measured

The latest ZIP-level figures from Miami Realtors and Florida Realtors cover July through September 2026. In that quarter, ZIP code 33133 recorded 68 single-family closings, up 61.9% from the third quarter of 2025. The median sale price was $2,825,000, up 20.2%. The average sale price was $3,901,811, up 24.6%. Buyers paid cash in 41 of those 68 sales, about 60%. In the same quarter, supply fell 33.8% to 4.7 months, and the median time to contract fell 12.8% to 41 days.

The Q3 2026 report is also useful for comparing the Grove with nearby ZIP codes over the same three months:

ZIP code, Q3 2026 Single-family closings Median sale price Median change, year over year
33133, Coconut Grove 68 $2,825,000 +20.2%
33129, north of the Grove 13 $2,190,000 +12.3%
33143, south and west 47 $1,950,000 −28.4%
33134, Coral Gables 55 $1,315,000 +4.2%
Miami-Dade County 2,591 $685,000 +3.8%

ZIP 33133 does not match the Grove's boundaries exactly, so its numbers are a stand-in for the neighborhood. Even so, they point in one direction. In Q3 2026 the average was about 38% higher than the median, so a group of very large sales is pulling the average up. Sales rose by more than half while supply fell by a third, so buyers took up houses faster than sellers listed them. A 60% cash share means most of those buyers did not need a lender's appraisal to close.

The record was set a mile from the water

The Miami Herald reported on August 4 that Sabal Development had sold a newly built house at 4040 Kiaora Street for $22.5 million. The Herald called it the most expensive non-waterfront home sale on record in Coconut Grove. The house sits in thick landscaping about a mile inland from Biscayne Bay.

Until recently, prices like that in the Grove came with bay frontage. The waterfront still leads. In September, The Real Deal reported that a waterfront home at 3575 Battersea Road, on a 0.9-acre site, sold for more than $80 million. The deal was reported as a change in ownership of the LLC that holds the property, with no recorded deed at the time. In October, The Real Deal reported that 3373 Poinciana Avenue was under contract at $17.4 million. It is a 1969 house on 50,000 square feet, including a 22,000-square-foot mangrove preserve and 60 feet of water frontage.

Compare the two below the Battersea level. A 1969 house on more than an acre of bayfront went under contract for $5.1 million less than a new house a mile inland. The bayfront property's value is in its land and its frontage. The Kiaora price is for a finished house that was ready on closing day. For a buyer who wants to move into a new house in the Grove, Kiaora is the more useful comparison.

Inland lots now come with a calendar

A finished house is worth more when building one takes longer. On November 5, Coconut Grove Spotlight reported that Miami residents had filed at least 22 appeals of tree-removal permits so far in 2026, compared with one in all of 2025. Tree disputes the Spotlight has covered this year include single-family projects in the Grove on South Moorings Way, Irvington Avenue and Swanson Avenue.

The Gifford Lane case shows the timing. According to the Spotlight's November 2 report, neighbors learned that seven trees were set for removal only after 14 months of city permit work. Two appeals later, the two sides agreed to remove one tree and keep six, and the project was still under review.

The rules may change. Miami's Tree Ordinance Advisory Committee began its review in July. Its members have given informal support to making mature trees more expensive to remove and giving owners more room to build around them. The committee is expected to send its proposals to the City Commission by March. At its November 9 meeting, builders asked the committee for simpler approvals and limits on appeals, the Spotlight reported on November 12. No recommendation has been adopted yet. For a buyer comparing a lot today with a finished house today, the time it takes to build on that lot is still uncertain.

We covered a similar split in Coral Gables earlier this month, where a city register now decides how fast a permit moves. In the Grove, the deciding factors are the trees on the lot and the neighbors who can see it.

The cottage route

TROPICA's projects are the third option. According to the Spotlight's November 9 profile, the firm founded by Andrew Aquart, Josh Ehrlich and Mariella Tzakis is designing and rebuilding nine cottages from the 1920s to the 1940s across the North, Center and South Grove. Each of those houses could have been torn down. On Swanson Avenue, one project keeps the original front of the house and marks the outline of the removed sections on the new addition.

The same article gives the cost. TROPICA's rebuilds average $500 to $800 per square foot. Levy Builders estimates that luxury custom new construction in Miami starts at $350 to $650 per square foot.

Restoring a cottage can cost more per square foot than building new. A buyer who chooses it is paying for things a construction estimate leaves out. The original house stays, so there is no demolition. The cottage is already part of the street, and the trees around it may not have to be cut. In a year with 22 tree appeals in the city, each of those things has a cost. It shows up in time, in carrying costs on a lot that sits unbuilt, and in whether the house can be finished at all.

Applying this to a Grove search

A buyer weighing a Grove house against a Coral Gables or Pinecrest house can start by placing the property in one of the three groups. Each one calls for a different way of judging price.

A finished new house is priced against Kiaora and against how hard it is to build another one. The Q3 2026 figures show that buyers paid for finished houses this year. Most paid cash, and they reached a contract in a median of 41 days.

A lot, or a house planned as a teardown, has to be priced with time built in. Count the large trees and check the street's recent history with the city. The months a project like Gifford Lane spent in review are a real carrying cost, and they belong in the offer.

An older cottage now has more value as something to keep. Nine projects underway across the North, Center and South Grove show that a restoration can produce a large modern house while the original structure stays.

Location still matters too. In Q3 2026, the Grove's median was more than double the Coral Gables ZIP median and $635,000 above the median just to the north in 33129. A buyer paying that premium should know which of the three groups the money is going toward. Our Coconut Grove neighborhood page and current Coconut Grove single-family listings can help with that comparison.

Frequently Asked Questions

Did Coconut Grove house prices really rise 20% this year? The median single-family sale price in ZIP 33133 rose 20.2% from Q3 2025 to Q3 2026, to $2,825,000. The average rose faster, so a share of that increase comes from a small number of very large sales.

What is the highest price paid for a non-waterfront home in the Grove? The Miami Herald reported in August 2026 that Sabal Development's newly built house at 4040 Kiaora Street sold for $22.5 million, a record for a Coconut Grove home without water frontage.

When might Miami's tree rules change? The city's Tree Ordinance Advisory Committee is expected to send its proposals to the City Commission by March. As of its November meetings, it had not formally adopted any recommendation.

Whether you are pricing a finished house on an inland street, a lot with mature trees, or a 1920s cottage worth keeping, Juliana Savoia Group can show you how comparable Grove properties are trading and what the time to build is worth in your offer. Request a Private Consultation, and we will go through the property's numbers with you before you commit.

Juliana Savoia

About the Author

Juliana Savoia is a top-producing Miami real estate professional ranked in the top .05% of Realtors® nationwide, with more than $350 million in transactions since 2020. Recognized five times by NAHREP’s Top 250 Latino Agents Award, she brings over a decade of experience helping clients achieve the unique Miami lifestyle through integrity, strategy, and global reach. With a background as an executive in finance and investment banking, Juliana expertly manages complex negotiations and contracts while delivering seamless, stress-free experiences for buyers and sellers alike. Fluent in six languages, she is uniquely positioned to serve both local and international clients with exceptional professionalism and care.

📍 4000 Ponce de Leon Blvd., #700, Coral Gables, FL 33146
📞 (305) 303-4410

Work With Juliana

Juliana prides herself in providing personalized solutions that bring her clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth.

Follow Us on Instagram